Skip navigation.

Bring back the Institute for Workers’ Control

Joe Guinan

 < 1 2 >

Corbyn’s leadership could open up space for a much broader political conversation, especially on economics, than has been possible in the UK for many decades. In his first conference speech as Shadow Chancellor, John McDonnell pledged that Labour would ‘promote modern alternative public, co-operative, worker controlled and genuinely mutual forms of ownership’ (McDonnell, 2015). At precisely the point when it appeared at its weakest historically, the Labour New Left has been granted an unexpected afterlife. It is greatly to be hoped that this does not devolve into a simple reprise of conventional Keynesianism, already tested to its limits in far friendlier conditions and found wanting.

Just as dangerous is the bandwagon, already rolling, that seeks to rehabilitate the so-called ‘soft left’ as a means of managing Corbynism and returning Labour to ‘electability’. This manoeuvre depends upon a bait-and-switch by which the historical ‘hard left’ is first marginalised by reducing a variegated and broad-based political movement to a cartoon of the Militant Tendency while a refurbished pluralist ‘soft left’, built around Marxism Today and trendy cultural theory, is proffered in its stead. Although it made a few interesting conceptual advances, the ‘soft left’ outside the Labour Party was a mash-up of post-Fordism and postmodernism amounting to, in one succinct verdict, ‘either futurology or bad history … Analytically erroneous, it was strategically divisive' (Elliott, 1993, 150-1). Somehow retrospectively granted exclusive rights to Gramsci and to social movements, in practice it took quiescence as its watchword, seeing hegemony as something to be ‘endured, not forged’ (Ibid, 151). Inside the Labour Party, the soft left’s record was still worse. As two close observers of the mafia politics of the Kinnock era noted, Labour’s own ‘Great Moving Right Show’ would hardly have been possible without:

the acquiescence of a sizable chunk of the rank and file, whose demoralisation and disorientation in the wake of successive defeats was skilfully exploited by the Party leadership. A key layer of activists, those former supporters of the “Bennite” insurgency, who came to be known as the “soft left”, proved themselves ready, willing, and able to make any compromise and abandon any principle as and when it suited the interdependent requirements of the leadership and their own personal interests. (Heffernan and Marqusee, 1992, 2)

It would be a final grim irony if, granted an unexpected afterlife, the political heirs of the Labour New Left were themselves to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory by either falling back into the arms of the Keynesianism against which they originally defined themselves or succumbing to the same ‘soft left’ blandishments that previously delivered over the party, bound hand and foot, to its real enemies within.

I would like to thank James Doran, who first planted the seed for this article, and Martin O’Neill for his helpful comments on an earlier draft.

 

References

Azzellini, D. (ed.) (2015) An Alternative Labour History: Worker Control and Workplace Democracy, London, Zed Books.

Barratt Brown, M. (1968) Opening the Books, Pamphlet Series No. 4, Nottingham, Institute for Workers’ Control.

Barratt Brown, M., Coates, K., Fleet, K., Fletcher, R., Nicholson, B., Silberman, F. and Topham, T. (1969) GEC-EE Workers’ Takeover, Pamphlet Series No. 17, Nottingham, Institute for Workers’ Control.

Barratt Brown, M. (1972) From Labourism to Socialism: The Political Economy of Labour in the 1970’s, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Barratt Brown, M. and Holland, S. (1973) Public Ownership and Democracy, Pamphlet Series No. 38, Nottingham, Institute for Workers’ Control.

Beynon, H. and Wainwright, H. (1979) The Workers’ Report on Vickers, London, Pluto Press.

Bogdanov, A. (1984) Red Star: The First Bolshevik Utopia, Bloomington, Indiana University Press.

Bristol Aircraft Workers (1974) A New Approach to Public Ownership, Pamphlet Series No. 43, Nottingham, Institute for Workers’ Control.

Cambridge Political Economy Group (1974) Britain’s Economic Crisis, Pamphlet Series No. 44, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Carr, E. (1952) A History of Soviet Russia: The Bolshevik Revolution 1917-1923, Vol. 2, London, Macmillan.

Chizik, M. (1970) Workers’ Participation in the Management of the Histadrut Economy, International Studies in Industrial Democracy No. 4, Nottingham, Institute for Workers’ Control.

Coates, D. (1975) The Labour Party and the Struggle for Socialism, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Coates, K. (1967) ‘The motor industry’, New Left Review 46: 86-8.

Coates, K. (ed.) (1968) Can the Workers Run Industry?, Bungay, Sphere Books and the Institute for Workers’ Control.

Coates, K. (ed.) (1969) Democracy in the Motor Industry, Nottingham, Institute for Workers’ Control.

Coates, K. (ed.) (1972) The Crisis of British Socialism: Essays on the Rise of Harold Wilson and the Fall of the Labour Party, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Coates, K. (ed.) (1972) Socialism and the Environment, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Coates, K. and Silburn, R. (1973) Poverty: The Forgotten Englishmen, Harmondsworth, Pelican.

Coates, K. and Topham, T. (1973) Catching Up With the Times: How Far the TUC Got the Message About Workers’ Control, Pamphlet Series No. 37, Nottingham, Institute for Workers’ Control.

Coates, K. (1976) The New Worker Co-operatives, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Coates, K. (1977) Beyond Wage Slavery, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Coates, K. and Topham, T. (1977) The Shop Steward’s Guide to the Bullock Report, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Coates, K. (1978) The Case of Nikolai Bukharin, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Coates, K. (ed.) (1979) What Went Wrong? Explaining the Fall of the Labour Government, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Coates, K. (1981) Work-ins, Sit-ins and Industrial Democracy, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Coates, K. (2003) Workers’ Control: Another World is Possible, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Coates, K. (ed.) (2007) The Right to Useful Work, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Collective Design/Projects (eds.) (1985) Very Nice Work If You Can Get It: The Socially Useful Production Debate, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Conference of Socialist Economists London Working Group (1980) The Alternative Economic Strategy: A Labour Movement Response to the Economic Crisis, London, CSE Books.

Dahl, R. (1947) ‘Workers’ control of industry and the British Labour Party’, American Political Science Review 41 (5): 875-900.

Dumas, L. and Thee, M. (eds.) (1989) Making Peace Possible: The Promise of Economic Conversion, Oxford, Pergamon Press.

Eaton, J., Hughes, J. and Coates, K. (1972) UCS Workers’ Control: The Real Defence Against Unemployment is Attack! Pamphlet Series No. 25, Nottingham, Institute for Workers’ Control.

Elliott, G. (1993) Labourism and the English Genius: The Strange Death of Labour England?, London, Verso.

Fine, S. (1969) Sit-Down: The General Motors Strike of 1936-37, Ann Arbor, University of Michigan Press.

Fleet, K. (1972) Whatever Happened at U.C.S.? Pamphlet Series No. 28, Nottingham, Institute for Workers’ Control.

Foster, J. (2000) Marx’s Ecology: Materialism and Nature, New York, Monthly Review Press.

Goodman, J. and Whittingham, T. (1969) Shop Stewards in British Industry, London, McGraw-Hill.

Goodrich, C. (1975) The Frontier of Control: A Study in British Workshop Politics, London, Pluto Press.

Heffernan, R. and Marqusee, M. (1992) Defeat From the Jaws of Victory: Inside Kinnock’s Labour Party, London, Verso.

Holland, S. (1975) The Socialist Challenge, London, Quartet Books.

Holland, S. (ed.) (1978) Beyond Capitalist Planning, New York, St. Martin’s Press.

Hoyles, A. (1973) Imagination in Power: The Occupation of Factories in France in 1968, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Hyman, R. (1979) Strikes, Glasgow, Fontana.

Institute for Workers’ Control (no date) Aims, Constitution and Membership, Nottingham, Institute for Workers’ Control.

Institute for Workers’ Control Motors Group (1978) A Workers’ Enquiry into the Motor Industry, London, The IWC Motors Group.

Lambie, G. (2012) ‘A political life: Ken Coates interviewed by George Lambie’, Spokesman 116: 19-45.

Lavaca Collective (2007) Sin Patrón: Stories from Argentina’s Worker-Run Factories, Chicago, Haymarket.

Lucas Aerospace Combine Shop Stewards’ Committee (1979) Democracy Versus the Circumlocution Office, Pamphlet Series No. 65, Nottingham, Institute for Workers’ Control.

Lydersen, K. (2009) Revolt on Goose Island: The Chicago Factory Takeover and What it Says About the Economic Crisis, New York, Melville House.

Marx, K. (1974) Capital, Volume I, London, Lawrence & Wishart.

McDonnell, J. (2015) ‘speech to Labour Party Annual Conference’, at http://press.labour.org.uk/post/130055656854/speech-by-john-mcdonnell-to-labour-party-annual.

McGill, J. (1973) Crisis on the Clyde, London, Davis-Poynter.

Medhurst, J. (2014) That Option No Longer Exists: Britain 1974-76, Alresford, Zero Books.

Mullin, C. (1980) How to Select or Reselect Your MP, Pamphlet Series No. 77, Nottingham, Campaign for Labour Party Democracy and Institute for Workers’ Control.

Ness, I. and Azzellini, D. (2011) Ours to Master and to Own: Workers’ Control from the Commune to the Present, Chicago, Haymarket.

Panitch, L. and Leys, C. (2001) The End of Parliamentary Socialism: From New Left to New Labour, London, Verso.

Pribićević, B. (1959) The Shop Stewards’ Movement and Workers’ Control 1910-1922, Oxford, Blackwell.

Roberts, E. (1971) The Solution is Workers’ Control, Pamphlet Series No. 19, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Roberts, E. (1973) Workers’ Control, London, George Allen & Unwin.

Rychetnik, L. (1969) Two Models of an Enterprise in Market Socialism, International Studies in Industrial Democracy No. 1, Nottingham, Institute for Workers’ Control.

Salvage (2015) ‘Amid this stony rubbish’, No. 1: 2-15.

Scanlon, H. (1968) The Way Forward for Workers’ Control, Pamphlet Series No. 1, Nottingham, Institute for Workers’ Control.

Sherry, D. (2010) Occupy! A Short History of Workers’ Occupations, London, Bookmarks Publications.

Spriano, P. (1975) The Occupation of the Factories: Italy 1920, London, Pluto Press.

Stokes, K. (1995) Paradigm Lost: A Cultural and Systems Theoretical Critique of Political Economy, London, M.E. Sharpe.

Thompson, N. (2002) Left in the Wilderness: The Political Economy of British Democratic Socialism since 1979, Chesham, Acumen.

Thompson, N. (2006) Political Economy and the Labour Party, London, Routledge.

Topham, T. (1967) Report of the Fifth National Conference on Workers’ Control and Industrial Democracy, Nottingham, Centre for Socialist Education.

Topham, T. (ed.) (1983) Planning the Planners: How to Control the Recovery, Nottingham, Spokesman.

Wainwright, H., and Elliott, D. (1982) The Lucas Plan: A New Trade Unionism in the Making?, London, Allison & Busby.

Wainwright, H. (1987) Labour: A Tale of Two Parties, London, Hogarth Press.

Wainwright, H. (1994) Arguments for a New Left: Answering the Free Market Right, Oxford, Blackwell.

Wark, M. (2015) Molecular Red: Theory for the Anthropocene, London, Verso.

 

Notes

1. Alexander Bogdanov appears to be enjoying a mini-revival: he also has a walk-on part in Paul Mason’s latest book. See pp. 218-21 in Mason, P. (2015) Postcapitalism: A Guide to Our Future, St. Ives, Allen Lane.

2. Although the Institute for Workers’ Control is sadly defunct, IWC publications are still available from Spokesman Books at: https://www.spokesmanbooks.com/acatalog/Institute_for_Workers_Control.html. Many IWC pamphlets are freely available on the website of Socialist Renewal at: http://www.socialistrenewal.net/node/121.

3. Frances O’Grady, General Secretary of the Trades Union Congress, gave the inaugural Ken Coates Memorial Lecture at the University of Nottingham on 3 June 2015. Audio of the lecture is available at: https://www.nottingham.ac.uk/cssgj/centre-activities/conferences-workshops/ken-coates-memorial-lecture.aspx.

 < 1 2 >
Renewal